• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to content
  • Skip to footer

Azevedo Nelson

Toronto Personal Injury Lawyer | Brampton Car Accident Lawyer | Mississauga

  • Home
  • Lawyers
    • Antonio F. Azevedo
    • Rebecca L. Nelson
    • William D. Ribeiro
    • Annie Zhuang
    • Edyta Kolpak
    • Dominik Gora
  • Areas of Practice
    • Personal Injury
    • Insurance Litigation
    • Occupiers Liability
    • Disability Benefit & CPP Appeals
    • Business Litigation
    • Construction Lien
    • Family Law
    • Mortgages
    • Short Term Disability
    • Long Term Disability
    • Residential Real Estate
  • Injury Types
    • Motor Vehicle Accident
    • Pedestrian Accident
    • Anxiety
    • Back Injury
    • Brain Injury
    • Broken Bones
    • Chronic Pain
    • PTSD
  • Consultation Offices
  • FAQ
  • Blog
  • Media
  • Contact

March 11, 2016

How to win an argument

Share:

TwitterFacebookLinkedinEmail

Recently, Justice Rothstein retired from the Supreme Court of Canada. He was a long serving judge and who saw some of the country’s best lawyers at work before him in the Supreme Court.

According to Rothstein the worst lawyers he saw at the Supreme Court were those that failed to fully understand the arguments of their opposing lawyers.

When I was a young lawyer, still learning my trade, a colleague told me that it was very important to be impartial. My first thought was: Why should I be impartial? I couldn’t imagine it because I thought my job was to argue as forcefully as possible for the position that was most favourable to my client. Wasn’t it up the judges to be impartial? Wasn’t it up the judges to listen to both sides and then decide? But that advice from my colleague always stayed with me and over time I began to think differently.

Lady justice holding scales at supreme court.

Photo by Rae Allen via CC BY 2.0

The real lesson is that to win an argument before a judge, you have to convince them not only that your argument is sound and supported by law, but that it’s better than the opposition’s argument. How is this done? You need to have credibility – if you have credibility they will listen to your arguments and if you don’t, they will tune you out instantly. And how do you establish credibility? By showing that you fully understand the facts and laws in play. And that means knowing the law and arguments that support both your position and the position of your opponent. I win when I am able to show that my argument is preferable to the argument of my opponent.

In other words, if you aren’t objective you will never have credibility. If you don’t fully understand your opponent’s arguments, you will never be able to convince a judge and win an argument.

And that’s why I say that it is always very important to listen carefully to the other side.

Filed Under: Canadian Law

Who’s responsible in a dog attack?

Who’s responsible in a dog attack?

Whether a dog is cute or ferocious depends on your point of view. As a dog owner, it's hard to... Read More
How long do CPP Disability Benefits last?

How long do CPP Disability Benefits last?

The Canada Pension Plan pays out disability benefits from the time you claim disability until age 65 or are no... Read More
The new Ontario Retirement Pension Plan vs. CPP disability claims

The new Ontario Retirement Pension Plan vs. CPP disability claims

Have you been seeing a lot of Premier Wynne in the newspapers lately? More so than usual? With the 2015... Read More

Reader Interactions

Personal injury lawyers with over 20 years experience proudly serving Toronto, the GTA and all of Ontario.

“We will not back down!”

Consultation offices are located in West Etobicoke, Kitchener, Brampton, Burlington, Oakville and Hamilton to serve you better.

Footer

Contact Us

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Copyright © 2023 · Azevedo & Nelson Professional Corporation | Sitemap | Blog